Local and regional minimum 1D models for earthquake location and data quality assessment in complex tectonic regions: application to Switzerland

One-dimensional (1D) velocity models are still widely used for computing earthquake locations at seismological centers or in regions where three-dimensional (3D) velocity models are not available due to the lack of data of sufficiently high quality. The concept of the minimum 1D model with appropriate station corrections provides a framework to compute initial hypocenter locations and seismic velocities for local earthquake tomography. Since a minimum 1D model represents a solution to the coupled hypocenter-velocity problem it also represents a suitable velocity model for earthquake location and data quality assessment, such as evaluating the consistency in assigning pre-defined weighting classes and average picking error. Nevertheless, the use of a simple 1D velocity structure in combination with station delays raises the question of how appropriate the minimum 1D model concept is when applied to complex tectonic regions with significant three-dimensional (3D) variations in seismic velocities. In this study we compute one regional minimum 1D model and three local minimum 1D models for selected subregions of the Swiss Alpine region, which exhibits a strongly varying Moho topography. We compare the regional and local minimum 1D models in terms of earthquake locations and data quality assessment to measure their performance. Our results show that the local minimum 1D models provide more realistic hypocenter locations and better data fits than a single model for the Alpine region. We attribute this to the fact that in a local minimum 1D model local and regional effects of the velocity structure can be better separated. Consequently, in tectonically complex regions, minimum 1D models should be computed in sub-regions defined by similar structure, if they are used for earthquake location and data quality assessmen

Combining controlled-source seismology and local earthquake tomography to derive a 3-D crustal model of the western Alpine region

We present a newly developed approach of combining controlled-source seismology (CSS) and local earthquake tomography (LET) data to obtain a new 3-D crustal model of the western Alpine region. Our approach combines either data by taking into account the strengths of the individual seismic methods. Our western Alpine 3-D model is primarily based on a well-defined Moho, constrained by CSS and LET data, and includes smooth lateral variations in seismic velocities mainly constrained by LET data, but locally also by CSS data. The consistent combination of results from the two different seismic methods is feasible due to LET Moho elements, as defined by characteristic P-wave velocities and their uncertainty estimates. These uncertainty estimates are based on values of the diagonal element of the resolution matrix, absolute P-wave velocities that are typical for crust and mantle and a specific velocity gradient across the Moho discontinuity. Finally, our definition of LET Moho elements and their uncertainties is validated by comparisons of highest quality Moho results from both methods coinciding in 353 localities. Our model clearly shows three Moho surfaces, being Europe, Adria and Liguria as well as major tectonic structures like suture zones and the high-velocity Ivrea body. In general, it is in a good agreement with previous studies. The biggest differences occur along plate boundaries, where the strong lateral velocity variations are best resolved by LET. Due to the larger number of available Moho reflector elements a more accurate definition of plate boundaries at Moho level is possible and, therefore, new insights in deep lithosphere structures of the Alpine collision zone can be expected. Furthermore, our new 3-D crustal model directly includes a 3-D migrated image of the Ivrea bod

Induced seismicity during the construction of the Gotthard Base Tunnel, Switzerland: hypocenter locations and source dimensions

A series of 112 earthquakes was recorded between October 2005 and August 2007 during the excavation of the MFS Faido, the southernmost access point of the new Gotthard Base Tunnel. Earthquakes were recorded at a dense network of 11 stations, including 2 stations in the tunnel. Local magnitudes computed from Wood-Anderson-filtered horizontal component seismograms ranged from −1.0 to 2.4; the largest earthquake was strongly felt at the surface and caused considerable damage in the tunnel. Hypocenter locations obtained routinely using a regional 3-D P-wave velocity model and a constant Vp/Vs ratio 1.71 were about 2km below the tunnel. The use of seismic velocities calibrated from a shot in the tunnel revealed that routinely obtained hypocenter locations were systematically biased to greater depth and are now relocated to be on the tunnel level. Relocation of the shot using these calibrated velocities yields a location accuracy of 25m in longitude, 70m in latitude, and 250m in focal depth. Double-difference relative relocations of two clusters with highly similar waveforms showed a NW-SE striking trend that is consistent with the strike of mapped faults in the MFS Faido. Source dimensions computed using the quasidynamic model of Madariaga (Bull Seismo Soc Am 66(3):639-666, 1976) range from 50 to 170m. Overlapping source dimensions for earthquakes within the two main clusters suggests that the same fault patch was ruptured repeatedly. The observed seismicity was likely caused by stress redistribution due to the excavation work in the MFS Faid

High-precision earthquake locations in Switzerland using regional secondary arrivals in a 3-D velocity model

We present a new approach to relocate earthquakes in the greater western Alpine region using main crustal phases (Pg, Pn, PmP) that takes advantage of recent developments in P-wave velocity models and modelling of the Moho topography in the region, as well as the ability to track reflected and refracted phases in three-dimensional (3-D) heterogeneous media. Our approach includes a new 3-D P-wave velocity model for Switzerland and surrounding regions that combines a first-order Moho discontinuity based on local earthquake tomography (LET) and controlled-source seismology (CSS) information and 3-D seismic velocity information based on LET. Traveltimes for the main crustal phases (Pg, Pn, PmP) are computed using a fast marching method. We use a non-linear, probabilistic approach to relocate earthquakes that has been extended to include the use of secondary phases. We validate our approach using synthetic data, which was computed for a real earthquake and different combinations of available phases (Pg, Pn, PmP). We also applied our approach to relocate four selected earthquakes, two shallow and two deep crustal events in the northern Alpine foreland, for which independent information (ground truth information) on their focal depths exist. Our results demonstrate that the precision and accuracy of focal depth estimates can be greatly improved if secondary phases are used. This gain is a combined effect of an improved range of take-off angles and the use of differential traveltimes between first and secondary arriving phases. Our results also show that reliable information on the Moho depth is crucial to obtain accurate focal depths, if Pn or PmP phases are used in the relocation process. Finally, our approach demonstrates that proper identification of the main crustal phases in combination with an appropriate model parametrization in the forward solver will significantly improve earthquake location

Earthquakes in Switzerland and surrounding regions during 2010

This report of the Swiss Seismological Service summarizes the seismic activity in Switzerland and surrounding regions during 2010. During this period, 407 earthquakes and 85 quarry blasts were detected and located in the region under consideration. With a total of only 19 events with ML≥2.5, the seismic activity in the year 2010 was below the average over the previous 35years. The two most noteworthy earthquakes were the ML3.4 Barrhorn event near Sankt Niklaus (VS) and the ML 3.0 event of Feldkirch, both of which produced shaking of intensity I

Earthquakes in Switzerland and surrounding regions during 2011

This report of the Swiss Seismological Service summarizes the seismic activity in Switzerland and surrounding regions during 2011. During this period, 522 earthquakes and 92 quarry blasts were detected and located in the region under consideration. With a total of only 10 events with M L≥2.5, the seismic activity in the year 2011 was far below the average over the previous 36years. Most noteworthy were the earthquake sequence of Sierre (VS) in January, with two events of M L 3.3 and 3.2, the M L 3.3 earthquake at a depth of 31km below Bregenz, and the M L 3.1 event near Delémont. The two strongest events near Sierre produced shaking of intensity I

Earthquakes in Switzerland and surrounding regions during 2011

This report of the Swiss Seismological Service summarizes the seismic activity in Switzerland and surrounding regions during 2011. During this period, 522 earthquakes and 92 quarry blasts were detected and located in the region under consideration. With a total of only 10 events with M L≥2.5, the seismic activity in the year 2011 was far below the average over the previous 36years. Most noteworthy were the earthquake sequence of Sierre (VS) in January, with two events of M L 3.3 and 3.2, the M L 3.3 earthquake at a depth of 31km below Bregenz, and the M L 3.1 event near Delémont. The two strongest events near Sierre produced shaking of intensity I

Earthquakes in Switzerland and surrounding regions during 2005

Abstract.: This report of the Swiss Seismological Service summarizes the seismic activity in Switzerland and surrounding regions during 2005. During this period, 611 earthquakes, 96 quarry blasts and two landslides were detected and located in the region under consideration. With 19 events with ML ≥ 2.5, the seismic activity in the year 2005 was below the average over the last 30 years. However, with the earthquake of Vallorcine (ML 4.9) located just across the border to France, between Martigny and Chamonix, and the two earthquakes of Rumisberg and Brugg (ML 4.1), located in the lower crust beneath the Jura Mountains of northern Switzerland, the year 2005 saw three events that produced shaking of intensity IV and V (EMS98). Of the 611 recorded earthquakes more than 110 events are aftershocks of the Vallorcine quake. Moreover, 51 events occurred within two days at the end of August during a period of very intense rainfalls. The epicenters of these events were concentrated in several clusters distributed over a wide area of central Switzerland, and their focal depths were shallow, so that they most likely constitute a case of precipitationinduced seismicit

Earthquakes in Switzerland and surrounding regions during 2013

This report of the Swiss Seismological Service summarizes the seismic activity in Switzerland and surrounding regions during 2013. During this period, 699 earthquakes and 208 quarry blasts were detected and located in the region under consideration. With a total of 18 events with local magnitudes ML ≥ 2.5, the seismic activity in the year 2013 was slightly below the average over the previous 38years. Most noteworthy were the two earthquake sequences of St. Gallen (SG) in July and Balzers (FL) in December. The former was induced by reservoir stimulation operations at the St. Gallen geothermal project. The maximum local magnitude in the sequence was 3.5, comparable in size with the ML 3.4 event induced by stimulation operations below Basel in 2006. The sequence of Balzers was associated with an ML 4.1 earthquake in the border region to Liechtenstein. More than 30 aftershocks with magnitudes ranging between ML −0.2 and ML 3.7 were detected in the month following the mainshock. The ML 3.5 St. Gallen and the ML 4.1 Balzers earthquakes were widely felt by the public but no reports on damages are known. The maximum intensity for both events was IV

Earthquakes in Switzerland and surrounding regions during 2013

This report of the Swiss Seismological Service summarizes the seismic activity in Switzerland and surrounding regions during 2013. During this period, 699 earthquakes and 208 quarry blasts were detected and located in the region under consideration. With a total of 18 events with local magnitudes ML ≥ 2.5, the seismic activity in the year 2013 was slightly below the average over the previous 38years. Most noteworthy were the two earthquake sequences of St. Gallen (SG) in July and Balzers (FL) in December. The former was induced by reservoir stimulation operations at the St. Gallen geothermal project. The maximum local magnitude in the sequence was 3.5, comparable in size with the ML 3.4 event induced by stimulation operations below Basel in 2006. The sequence of Balzers was associated with an ML 4.1 earthquake in the border region to Liechtenstein. More than 30 aftershocks with magnitudes ranging between ML −0.2 and ML 3.7 were detected in the month following the mainshock. The ML 3.5 St. Gallen and the ML 4.1 Balzers earthquakes were widely felt by the public but no reports on damages are known. The maximum intensity for both events was IV